Chest Closure after Heart Surgery
Less Invasive Prototype Replaces Metal Wires
with Polymer Cable Ties
To operate on the heart, surgeons usually cut through the breastbone. After correcting the heart problem, they reconnect the sternum by piercing it with steel wires, pulling the bone segments together and twisting the wires tight. Because this half-century-old technique poses some risks to both the surgeon and the patient, undergraduates at The Johns Hopkins University have invented a less intrusive and potentially safer chest closure system that threads locking polymer clasps through the ribs.
The 11-member team's prototype won first-place honors in the university's recent Biomedical Engineering Design Day competition. The project's sponsor, Surgical Transformations LLC, has obtained a provisional patent covering the system. If the idea appeals to enough surgeons, the firm plans to support further research and development to produce a commercial model.
Malcolm Lloyd, a physician and co-owner of the company, said he and his partner, heart surgeon Mark Sumeray, challenged the students last year to devise a better way to close the chest after surgery. "The premise was based on an unmet need identified by cardiothoracic surgeons," Lloyd said. "The students came up with a working prototype that hit all of the engineering requirements we proposed. The end result was better than my partner and I expected, particularly given the limitations they had in terms of resources."
The students produced their prototype, which resembles a
stapler and uses standard locking cable ties, for about
$1,500. Much of this went to a private prototyping shop
that built the device according to the students' detailed
design drawings. A roughly 8-inch curved piece extends from
the handheld tool to guide the tie between and under the
ribs, enabling a surgeon to connect both ends and pull the
severed sternum parts toward one another. When one end of
the tie is reinserted into the tool and the handles are
squeezed, the device operates like a ratchet, tightening
the clasp and bringing the pieces of the breastbone firmly
together so that the healing process can begin.
In a class called Biomedical Engineering Design Teams, the project was adopted last fall by a group led by Chris Weier, a 23-year-old senior from Sterling Heights, Mich., and Neha Malhotra, a 20-year-old junior from Dubai, United Arab Emirates. As part of their research over two semesters, team members visited a human cadaver lab to study chest anatomy. They conducted tests in a hospital biomechanics lab to see how the polymer ties compared to the steel wires. Members of the team, which included six freshmen, three juniors and two seniors, also worked with a model chest skeleton.
"Everyone was really involved, and everyone made a contribution to the project," Malhotra said. "Getting a provisional patent made the team feel like we really accomplished something."
Weier added: "This was not just a textbook problem. This was like a real-life industrial project with deadlines and patent searches."
If the prototype advances through further development and testing, many patients could benefit, the student inventors said. According to their research, the vertical cut in the breastbone, called a median sternotomy, was done in more than 700,000 operations worldwide in 2002 alone. The students also learned that the traditional method of reconnecting the sternum can cause injury because of the significant force needed to pierce the breastbone in order to accommodate the steel wires. They learned that these wires can sometimes cut through the bone if they are pulled too tight or can lead to poor bone reconnection if they are left too loose.
"We talked to doctors and asked them what would be an ideal system," Weier said. "They said it would be a band that they could tighten. It needed to be very rigid, as tight as possible without cutting into the bone, the flatter the better so that it could lay flat against the bone."
The team members concluded that their system was a safer approach. "We think it will reduce potential injuries to both the patients and the surgeons because the surgeon isn't physically pushing a needle through a bone," Malhotra said.
Although the students used commercial cable ties for their prototype, they said patients would best be served by a biocompatible polymer clasp that would dissolve harmlessly in the body after two years, when the sternum is fully healed.
Lloyd, the project's sponsor, watched a demonstration of the finished prototype and walked away impressed. "I think it was a great learning experience for the students," said Lloyd, who earned a bachelor's degree in biomedical engineering at Johns Hopkins in 1994.
Along with Weier and Malhotra, the student design team members included Matt David, Win Pin Ng, Paromita Chatterjee, Mikhail "Mike" Basilyan, Eric Kim, Alex King, Barbara Ma, Taylor Reese and Injeoung "Kate" Shim.
High-resolution color images of the team leaders and the system are available; contact Phil Sneiderman.
Follow this link to more images related to this news release.
Go to Headlines@HopkinsHome Page