The Johns Hopkins Gazette: December 6, 1999
December 6, 1999
VOL. 29, NO. 15


Earth's Core May Contain Cold Front of Molten Iron

By Michael Purdy
Johns Hopkins Gazette Online Edition

One of the world's biggest cold fronts might be under our feet rather than over our heads, according to results from Earth scientists at Johns Hopkins. Stranger still, there's a chance this cold front produces iron "snow" or "frost."

Writing in the Nov. 19 issue of Science, Hopkins researchers describe a laboratory experiment designed to model conditions in the outer core of the Earth, which is composed of molten iron. The laboratory results point to the possibility that a thin jet of relatively cold molten iron is streaming down across the liquid outer core from an area in the mid-Pacific to Earth's solid iron inner core.

Ikuro Sumita, a postdoctoral researcher and lead author on the paper, cautions that the new model is a "working hypothesis." There are many questions and concerns still to be addressed. But he has developed several tantalizingly direct ways to use the model to answer questions about observations relating to the Earth's core.

The Earth's molten outer core lies beneath the rocky mantle, which includes the surface. Earth scientists think of the mantle as the "master" that directs the activity of the outer core, which acts like a "slave" in response. Because of this close relationship, understanding the core's activity should help scientists better understand the mantle's behavior.

However, it's not possible to observe directly the outer core. Scientists can image the solid inner core using energy from earthquakes, known as seismic waves. But this reveals little of the liquid outer core.

"What we have to rely on instead to study the outer core is Earth's magnetic field, which is produced by the flow of molten iron," says Sumita.

Scientists can link changes in the strength and direction of magnetic fields above ground to the ebb and flow of molten iron below ground, Sumita explains. "For example, we can interpret the westward motion of the magnetic field patches as a manifestation of the westward flow in the core," he notes.

For their study, Sumita and co-author Peter Olson (pictured at right), professor of Earth and Planetary Sciences, modeled flow patterns in the Earth's core using a water-filled, rotating hemisphere with a solid chilled sphere at its center. A heater was placed at one spot on the rim of the hemisphere to imitate the uneven transfer of heat between the mantle and the outer core. Because the direction of the centrifugal gravity in the experiment is opposite to that of the Earth, this corresponds to a cold region found in the lower mantle of the Earth that causes a downward flow in the core.

Researchers set the model rotating at 206 revolutions per minute, injected a fluorescent dye into the water and filmed the resulting patterns. A thin spiral-shaped jet moving opposite the direction of the rest of the water soon emerged. In a manner similar to a weather front, the jet, which spiraled down to the solid sphere at the model's center, marked out the boundary between hot high-pressure areas and cool low-pressure zones in the water.

"We know that the seismic waves travel unusually fast in the lowermost region of the mantle beneath East Asia," Sumita says. "This is often interpreted as being due to a cold plate which has sunk into the bottom of the mantle from the surface of the Earth. Such a cold region would cause the core to lose a great deal of heat there."

A spiraling jet of cold iron starting east of that area could account for irregularities in the magnetic patterns observed over the Pacific. For example, there are fewer westward drifting magnetic patches in this area, which could be a result of the front blocking the westward flow of iron as well as the upward flow of hot iron.

"It may be that the colder mass of fluid west of the front causes the iron to solidify more in one region and accounts for this uneven east-west buildup," Sumita explains.

Missing in Sumita's theory is a mechanism that would keep the cold spot in East Asia cold for a long time. The buildup in the Earth's inner core is very slow, and to have shaped that buildup, the spiral would need to have been in place for millions of years.

Another potential wrinkle is the possibility that the solid inner core rotates, in which case the buildup should be more even.

"To follow up," Sumita says, "I will have to summarize the conditions needed for the existence of this jet and the front based upon the experiments I did with different heater magnitudes and sizes."

Further evidence on the potential merits of Sumita and Olson's model could come from high-resolution seismic imaging of the structure of the lowermost mantle and the inner core.

Olson published a study in the Nov. 11 issue of Nature that examined the flow near the polar region of the outer core, and is complementary to the present work, which examines the flow in the lower latitudes of the outer core.

Sumita's research was supported by the Research Fellowships of the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science for Young Scientists. The experiments were supported by the Geophysics Program of the National Science Foundation.