Headlines at Hopkins: news releases from across
the 
university Headlines
@Hopkins
News by Topic: news releases organized by subject News by Topic
News by School: news releases organized by the 
university's 9 schools & divisions News by School
Events Open to the Public (campus-wide) Events Open
to the Public
Blue Jay Sports: Hopkins Athletic Center Blue Jay Sports
Search News Site Search the Site

Contacting the News Staff: directory of university 
press officers Contacting
News Staff
Receive News Via Email (listservs) Receive News
Via Email
Resources for Journalists Resources for Journalists

Virtually Live@Hopkins: audio and video news Virtually
Live@Hopkins
Hopkins in the News: news clips about Hopkins Hopkins in
the News

Faculty Experts: searchable resource organized by 
topic Faculty Experts
Faculty and Administrator Photos Faculty and
Administrator
Photos
Faculty with Homepages Faculty with Homepages

JHUNIVERSE Homepage JHUniverse Homepage
Headlines at Hopkins
Media Advisory

Office of News and Information
Johns Hopkins University
3003 N. Charles Street, Suite 100
Baltimore, Maryland 21218-3843
Phone: (410) 516-7160 | Fax (410) 516-5251

December 3, 2001
MEDIA ADVISORY
CONTACT: Glenn Small
[email protected]


To: Reporters, Editors, Producers
Fr: Glenn Small, 410-516-7160, [email protected]
Re: Expert: Bush administration tribunals are unconstitutional

Joel Grossman, a political scientist at Johns Hopkins and an expert on the Supreme Court and constitutional law, says that the Bush administration's order establishing military tribunals is unconstitutional, although he concedes that the high court historically has been reluctant to intervene in times of armed conflict.

Writing for "Find Law's Writ," Grossman states, "There are several reasons why the plan for military tribunals is more than merely 'careless with the Constitution.' The preamble to President Bush's executive order reveals some very dubious claims that executive authority, either alone, or pursuant to acts of Congress, allows the creation of these tribunals.

"In fact," Grossman continues, "neither the President's commander-in-chief status, nor whatever inherent powers the Constitution allows him, nor any act of Congress, has properly authorized these tribunals."

Unlike military tribunals established by President Roosevelt during World War II, the Bush tribunals have been created without approval from Congress, said Grossman, and they send a dangerous message. "Treating citizens and non citizens in such dramatically disparate ways undercuts our tradition of treating all persons equally before the law. ... The Department of Justice motto that, 'The government wins when justice is done,' seems to have been replaced by, 'The government wins when convictions are certain.'"

Grossman, a scholar with more than 30 years of experience studying the Supreme Court and its decisions, is available for interviews. To set up an interview, please call 410-516-7160.

To read Grossman's commentary in full, please see writ.news.findlaw.com/commentary/20011129_grossman.html.


Johns Hopkins University news releases can be found on the World Wide Web at http://www.jhu.edu/news_info/news/
   Information on automatic e-mail delivery of science and medical news releases is available at the same address.


Go to Headlines@HopkinsHome Page